Another Gold and a question

Got a Gold from a judge in a recent club's competition plus the first place from the club members in Open Projected category (the first image without the signature of course).

Now I am thinking if I should have better left the reflections complete in as in the second image? 

190519_wa_greenbushes_071623-web-v1.jpg
190519_wa_greenbushes_071623-web-v2.jpg